a repeatedly asked question.
In this installment of Ask Jill, Jill answers a question individually queried by several different cyber-entities. Given Jill's aural fixation, it is not surprising that many of the folks she regularly interacts with are aural-obsessed as well. Even less surprising, then, that they would ask this question:
Does Jill have one of those famous New York accents?
Dear God, no!
Jill went to an all-girls Catholic high school where she spent four years in competitive speech, performance, and mock trial tournaments, under the tutelage of a nun who could have been a linebacker who tortured the Brooklyn out of Jill.
Actually, we should say the Brooklyn was dialed-down. And stored away. Because a New York accent is like any other language--useful as a second language in a pinch; comes in handy in emergency situations. It is also like any other abandoned mother tongue in that it is often returned to under severe stress or the influence of excessive amounts of alcohol.
Granted, Jill is lazy. Though well-trained by acting and speech instructors to articulate in Standard American English, in comfortable company she says "gonna" instead of "going to" and uses identifiable New York regionalisms that would severely displease Sister Linebacker. Let it be understood, however, that "youse" is never anywhere in the Jill Lexicon.
Also granted, there are some people in Jill's Real Life Circles who seem to think that even the soft usage of lazy regionalisms is reason to be condescended upon, especially when they believe people from their region to be superior to / classier than native outer borough New Yorkers simply by virtue of their birth or street address. (Gosh, did that sound a bit bitter?)
Jill does not agree. The full and proper articulation of every phonetic entity is rather exhausting, and actually--though not to be construed as a license to be inarticulate--Jill finds it hard to trust any person who doesn't now and again take a phonetic shortcut. Especially among friends.
Slang is a beautiful thing. Use it among friends, and--just like big words--when nothing else would say it better.
Does Jill have one of those famous New York accents?
Dear God, no!
Jill went to an all-girls Catholic high school where she spent four years in competitive speech, performance, and mock trial tournaments, under the tutelage of a nun who could have been a linebacker who tortured the Brooklyn out of Jill.
Actually, we should say the Brooklyn was dialed-down. And stored away. Because a New York accent is like any other language--useful as a second language in a pinch; comes in handy in emergency situations. It is also like any other abandoned mother tongue in that it is often returned to under severe stress or the influence of excessive amounts of alcohol.
Granted, Jill is lazy. Though well-trained by acting and speech instructors to articulate in Standard American English, in comfortable company she says "gonna" instead of "going to" and uses identifiable New York regionalisms that would severely displease Sister Linebacker. Let it be understood, however, that "youse" is never anywhere in the Jill Lexicon.
Also granted, there are some people in Jill's Real Life Circles who seem to think that even the soft usage of lazy regionalisms is reason to be condescended upon, especially when they believe people from their region to be superior to / classier than native outer borough New Yorkers simply by virtue of their birth or street address. (Gosh, did that sound a bit bitter?)
Jill does not agree. The full and proper articulation of every phonetic entity is rather exhausting, and actually--though not to be construed as a license to be inarticulate--Jill finds it hard to trust any person who doesn't now and again take a phonetic shortcut. Especially among friends.
Slang is a beautiful thing. Use it among friends, and--just like big words--when nothing else would say it better.
Labels: ask Jill, aurally-obsessed


15 Comments:
Jill went to an all-girls Catholic high school
I love posts that start that way.
By
Peter DeWolf, At
Wed Dec 27, 03:03:00 PM 2006
Jill, I sympathize. You've heard my clear, clipped, Mid-Western English, but that was only when I was being on my best linguistic behavior for the funny, little recording software. Both of my parents are originally from the South Side of Chicago and, as such, occasionally slip into similar "regionalisms". For instance, when excited, they might have said "Bot' adem are from da Sout' Side a Chicaga." And, yes, it does, on occasion, have advantages. Especially in the South where they think everyone from Chicago is a gangster.
Yo.
By
Network Geek, At
Wed Dec 27, 03:12:00 PM 2006
Somehow, Jill seems to make so many stereotypes about Catholic school girls that much more exciting.
Do you still have that "reply via real voice" thing going? If you do, I think you should make it a sidebar item. (Although, you may have already don that and I didn't notice.)
I'm glad you're feeling well enough to post a little, Jill.
By
-J, At
Wed Dec 27, 03:26:00 PM 2006
This message comes from a girl raised in Jersey and living in NY for the past 7 years. I've got a nice mixture of an accent. It's quite fun, I think. :)
By
Bryna, At
Wed Dec 27, 03:59:00 PM 2006
you are to funny.
By
Sass, At
Wed Dec 27, 04:15:00 PM 2006
You gonna record this or wha?
By
ChickyBabe, At
Wed Dec 27, 05:23:00 PM 2006
When I think about all the things I heart about NY, the accent tied to the city is one thing I don't love. Stanton Island accent is the worst! Thankfully though, not all New Yorkers have the "thug" accent. Almost all cities have their own accent and slang, but it's breaking free of the mold that we must strive for. Youse know what I'm talkin' bout.
By
DIAMONDKT, At
Wed Dec 27, 11:25:00 PM 2006
So that's why alcohol and temper flares turn me in to a less educated version of Jeb.
By
Casey, At
Wed Dec 27, 11:53:00 PM 2006
Actually, Jill, I'm glad to hear that you have for the most part stifled the accent. I don't think there's anything wrong with enunciation and proper pronunciation -- I find it not exhausting but classy.
Besides, there are so few accents that aren't Aussie, British or Irish that actually make a person sound anywhere near intelligent, no? Let's all be honest -- whether it's fair or not... stereotypically, what's the first thing one does when mocking someone of lesser perceived intelligence? That's right: we affect an accent.
I'm not saying it's fair or accurate, but in general... be it a slow Suthun drawl, da gise in Chicaga talkin' 'bout da Berse, the southies in Boston pahkin' theah cah in Hahvid Yahd, youse Noo Yawkiz, or oh yah, da Minnesoatins I grew up around talkin' like da movie Fargo dere, you betcha... there are very few US accents that are pleasing to the ear or make the speaker sound anything but less intelligent than they most likely are.
Aussies or Irish or English, on the other hand... hubba hubba.
Just one diction snob's opinion.
By
The Chronic Curmudgeon, At
Thu Dec 28, 11:18:00 AM 2006
Did you say "all girls Catholic high school"?? Okay, where are those photos?
By
kapgar, At
Thu Dec 28, 01:45:00 PM 2006
I want to respond to everyone, but right now I feel the overwhelming need to point out something to the Mudge. I agree with you up until a point, but then you make a gross oversimplification, I would say due to reverse Americentrism. The other accents of which you speak are nuanced as well, and if you spend enough time listening to them, you will be able to discern the same levels of articulateness among their speakers. Once you can do that, it's not hubba hubba all the time.
By
Jill, At
Thu Dec 28, 02:15:00 PM 2006
A fair point indeed, Jill. I stand corrected on the hubba hubba-ing.
Okay... now, can Peter DeWolf, Kapgar, Corey and I take turns writing the next few entries that begin, Jill went to an all-girls Catholic high school?
Pleeeeease? ;-)
By
The Chronic Curmudgeon, At
Thu Dec 28, 04:13:00 PM 2006
Go right ahead... Though I was sorta hoping not to get banned by anyone's (uh... anyone else's...) IT department. People read me at work, you know.
By
Jill, At
Fri Dec 29, 02:43:00 AM 2006
Now you've got me super curious to hear your voice. Cute post.
By
Megan, At
Fri Dec 29, 03:26:00 AM 2006
Irish accents sound intelligent? Since when. Every Irish person I talk to sounds like a drunken boob.
I had an Australian girlfriend in college and you're right, the accent definitely hid the fact that she was as dumb as a rock.
By
Corey, At
Sat Dec 30, 04:11:00 AM 2006
Post a Comment
<< Home