Monday, January 16, 2006

Literary Crushing, Not Necessarily Hetero

In the comments on my Good Ways to Ruin Your Life for the Sake of Inspiration post, Popeye shared his appreciation of the character of Atticus Finch. I began a reply, then realized it would take a bit more than just a comment paragraph to respond. On my homepage, I have a list of (male) fictional characters I have lusted after. (I'd provide the link, but my homepage is all in one Flash file, and therefore I cannot currently link separate pages. I'd love for you to read it, though. It's under "Lists".) But I don't have a list of female characters. So without further ado...

Jill's Possible Same Sex Literary Crushes

1. Hermione Granger from the Harry Potter series was the first one to come to mind. She's a geek; she mothers her friends, well; she always knows where to find the information to help save their asses, and has put her own on the line more than a few times; she charmed the heck out of Viktor Krum, world-famous Quidditch star. Sure, maybe early on, her hair needed a deep-conditioning treatment, but I think she's learned to take care of that. Especially now that she's clearly got her heart set on the oh-so-oblivious Ron. This choice might make me a pedophile...but just a fictional one, right? At least I didn't say Lolita.

2. Next, I thought of Arwyn of Lord of the Rings fame. Except I don't think I actually have a crush on her. It's more like I want her immortality, or her man. Or both. She's not really fiesty enough for me. I'd love to slay her and take her place. Which is something Eowyn could have done. Now, there's a crush-worthy Tolkien woman.

3. Tinkerbell. Forget. Wendy.

At this point, this list becomes a truly informative exercise. Because, if I am limiting myself to literature...well, there aren't a whole heckuvalotof female characters that entice me. Let's examine Shakespeare. Lady Macbeth is trying to act out her own ambitions through her husband, Ophelia can't cope, Gertrude is either an adultress or too easily manipulated, Miranda is sheltered, Juliet is naive, as is poor Desdemona, Cleopatra is...Cleopatra, Cordelia is somewhat likable, though her sisters clearly aren't, the girls in Midsummer's are too simple (it is a romantic comedy, after all), but...

4. Beatrice. What a wit! And fiesty indeed.

5. Katharina. The Shrew. Taming, my ass.

6. Elphaba. From Wicked. I don't care if she's green. No, I haven't seen the musical. I may be the only person in New York, or that has visited New York in the past year or two, that hasn't. I'll get around to it.

7. Catherine, of the Pulitzer Prize-winning David Auburn play, Proof. Young but complex. Plagued by people making false assumptions about her. Some of them false, anyway. Deadpan humor. And brilliant.

8. Sabine. From Nick Bantock's Griffin & Sabine series. Bantock is an artist, illustrator, writer and creator of pop-up books. This series tells the story through the correspondence of the title characters. Each page--their letters, postcards, and the like--is an artwork. And Sabine is the mysterious woman who initiates it all. If you're the type of person who wanders through bookstores looking for things to touch, and flip through, and lose yourself in, sit down with these. The text is limited enough to read over one cup of tea, but you really won't want to leave without the book(s).

Literary crushes, anyone?

Labels: , , ,

25 Comments:

  • I don't have literary crushes. I don't need to go that far to pine after they who are completely inaccessable.

    Oh, hey, I guess men do pine. That answered someone's question from some other comment, I think. *sigh* If only I could cook ennui and slice it thin, I'd never have to buy lunchmeat again.

    By Anonymous Network Geek, At 1/16/2006 02:08:00 PM  

  • I am SO glad that someone in this time zone appreciates Nick Bantock. I know he is well-marketed in British Columbia. It's good to see that he reaches beyond.

    Sabine, though? You're brave. Regular women are cryptic enough. Besides, I'm not so sure she's a she.

    By Anonymous peefer, At 1/16/2006 02:39:00 PM  

  • This is a perfect example of something a female can do and seem a little sexy while, if a man did it, it would just seem creepy or odd.

    Comedian Zach Galifianakis once observed: Why is it okay for a woman to say, 'I'm going out with my girlfriend,' and they hold hands on their way to the mall and such, but if I say, 'Me and my boyfriend are going to go shopping for fanny packs, everyone assumes that I'm a gay?

    I don't have a crush on Hermione Granger. I'm a large, hairy, thirty-something year-old man, and that would just be wrong. Plus, she won't return my emails, so screw her.

    Hello, Jill.

    By Blogger scott, At 1/16/2006 02:42:00 PM  

  • somebody left with my copy of Sabine...

    By Blogger at the Lake, At 1/16/2006 03:37:00 PM  

  • Buttercup (The Princess Bride by William Goldman aka S. Morgenstern). Padme and Leia from Star Wars(I am a little weirded out by the Mommy Daughter crush though). Fermina Daza (Love in the Time of Cholera by Gabriel Garcia Marquez). I may think of more later.

    By Blogger lil'bitty, At 1/16/2006 03:58:00 PM  

  • I saw Beatrice just yesterday. She was in fine form.

    By Anonymous anne arkham, At 1/16/2006 04:17:00 PM  

  • I'm also fond of Clytemnestra. And Medea. I have issues.

    By Anonymous anne arkham, At 1/16/2006 04:24:00 PM  

  • oh my god, i love sabine.

    and Beatrice. she's the reason my first car was named "b".

    By Blogger suze, At 1/16/2006 04:33:00 PM  

  • Katchen, from Waugh's "Scoop", she sailed off with my heart...

    ...and the girl on pages eight through fifteen of my illustrated "joy of sex", but she's only a drawing.

    By Blogger a fish on a bycicle, At 1/16/2006 04:57:00 PM  

  • are we talking same sex crushes here? because if we are, i'm gonna have to think about it for a bit.

    By Blogger kat, At 1/16/2006 05:13:00 PM  

  • Very creative Jill. I laughed at taming my ass.
    Ha!

    By Blogger Sass, At 1/16/2006 05:15:00 PM  

  • Yay! Men pine! Sorry to revel in your suffering, Geek, but it's good to know we women aren't alone.

    Peefer, did I miss something in those books, or are you just projecting phantoms of your twisted brain onto the character?

    Hello, Scott. Sorry your fictional teenage witch crush won't return your email. Maybe they don't have the internets at Hogwarts.

    I would so not be cool if someone tried to heist these books off my desk, At the Lake.

    Hey Lil Bitty, The Princess Bride was one of my favorites, but I'm sure your daddy would not want you to turn out to be SUCH A PRISS! WHO WOULD STAND BY AND LET HER MAN GET HIS BUTT HANDED TO HIM BY A RODENT! I'm going to address my film and tv crushes one of these days. Haven't yet read that book, but it's in my pile.

    Anne, Thinking Violet is a dear friend of mine. She wrote a play in which the protagonist identifies a wee bit too much with Medea. I think the two of you would get along famously.

    Cool, Suze. My first car was called "Ick". Because it was a Buick. That unfortunately lost its "Bu".

    Verrrrry interesting, Fish.

    Yes, Kat, but opposite sex crushes are also welcome topics of discussion. Bring 'em on.

    Thanks, Sass.

    By Blogger Jill, At 1/16/2006 05:16:00 PM  

  • Your number one would be my number one also. That Hermione is cute and you just have to love her character.

    By Blogger Egan, At 1/16/2006 07:26:00 PM  

  • Hermione is adorable in all her geekiness. The movies made her too cute though I think, and less nerdy than she is written.

    By Blogger Danielle, At 1/16/2006 08:41:00 PM  

  • I'm shocked that I'm the first one to say this ... and glad, because that means I have a better shot ... Elizabeth Bennet. Oh, sweet lord, Elizabeth Bennet. The brains, the wit, the attitude. As my first literary crush (unless we're going to go way back and include Harriet the Spy), she holds a special place in my heart.

    By Blogger SHEPHERD, At 1/16/2006 08:52:00 PM  

  • Um...er...no...just my own BlogFiction characters. Does that count?

    By Blogger ChickyBabe, At 1/16/2006 09:14:00 PM  

  • I figured you for a Hermione kinda guy, Egan.

    And I think you're right, Danielle.

    Shepherd, I did consider putting Elizabeth Bennet on my list. I actually wrote one of my college admissions essays about her!

    Sure that counts, ChickyBabe. Clearly, I've got a raging crush on Damon if I made him a damn CD! What a shame he's not real...

    By Blogger Jill, At 1/16/2006 09:35:00 PM  

  • How could you forget Mr Darcy from Pride and prejudice??? ohhh how i lust after him.

    By Blogger Steph, At 1/16/2006 10:12:00 PM  

  • Well, now that we've got a testosterone safe addendum, I'll play along. Though, of course, it's totally out of character for me, pining not withstanding.

    She's a bit obscure, but Gwen Delvano from Dying of the Light by George R. R. Martin.

    Jody, the red-headed vampire from Bloodsucking Fiends and Jenny, the waitress in Practical Demonkeeping, both by Christopher Moore.

    And, of course, the infamous Bridget Jones. What's not to love?

    By Anonymous Network Geek, At 1/16/2006 10:18:00 PM  

  • Steph, he's in my original (male) list.

    Geek, I've not read any of these (except Bridget Jones, and that I just thumbed through because I was too busy bitching that I could have written it), but now you've given me a mini-adventure the next time I feel like killing time in Barnes & Noble.

    By Blogger Jill, At 1/16/2006 10:19:00 PM  

  • Would I be a total kiss ass if I said you? Since I haven't met you yet, you could actually be a fictional character, ya know.

    I'll have to think of a serious answer, though. I'm realizing that most of my fictional character crushes are all men, simply because those are the characters I most love. That sucks.

    By Blogger Megan, At 1/16/2006 10:20:00 PM  

  • Good, then I'm sane!! Or we're both mad...

    By Blogger ChickyBabe, At 1/16/2006 10:31:00 PM  

  • Megan, I would be flattered and delighted to be your fictional same sex crush. Please do share your opposite sex literary crushes! I actually had to think about the female ones as well. Tinkerbell is really the only one that I think about regularly! So what does that say about me?

    ChickyBabe--yep that's been my conclusion all along. Either we are proof of each other's sanity, or we'll be roommates in the looney bin.

    By Blogger Jill, At 1/16/2006 10:33:00 PM  

  • Brigid O'Shaughnessy... Maltese Falcon.

    Cora Smith... The Postman Always Rings Twice by James M. Cain.

    I like bad girls, I guess.

    By Blogger The Chronic Curmudgeon, At 1/16/2006 11:55:00 PM  

  • Ah, insight into the curmudgeonly one...

    By Blogger Jill, At 1/17/2006 02:35:00 PM  

Post a Comment



<< Home